News • Diagnostic disorder

Psychiatric diagnosis ‘scientifically worthless’, says study

A new study has concluded that psychiatric diagnoses are scientifically worthless as tools to identify discrete mental health disorders.

The study, published in Psychiatry Research and led by researchers from the University of Liverpool, involved a detailed analysis of five key chapters of the latest edition of the widely used Diagnostic and Statistical Manual (DSM), on ‘schizophrenia’, ‘bipolar disorder’, ‘depressive disorders’, ‘anxiety disorders’ and ‘trauma-related disorders’. Diagnostic manuals such as the DSM were created to provide a common diagnostic language for mental health professionals and attempt to provide a definitive list of mental health problems, including their symptoms.

‘A disingenuous categorical system’

woman with blurry face sitting in a chair

Photo: Unsplash/Raphaela Vergud

The main findings of the research were:

  • Psychiatric diagnoses all use different decision-making rules
  • There is a huge amount of overlap in symptoms between diagnoses
  • Almost all diagnoses mask the role of trauma and adverse events
  • Diagnoses tell us little about the individual patient and what treatment they need

The authors conclude that diagnostic labelling represents ‘a disingenuous categorical system’.

Lead researcher Dr Kate Allsopp, University of Liverpool, said: “Although diagnostic labels create the illusion of an explanation they are scientifically meaningless and can create stigma and prejudice. I hope these findings will encourage mental health professionals to think beyond diagnoses and consider other explanations of mental distress, such as trauma and other adverse life experiences.”

Perhaps it is time we stopped pretending that medical-sounding labels contribute anything to our understanding of the complex causes of human distress

John Read

Professor Peter Kinderman, University of Liverpool, said: “This study provides yet more evidence that the biomedical diagnostic approach in psychiatry is not fit for purpose. Diagnoses frequently and uncritically reported as ‘real illnesses’ are in fact made on the basis of internally inconsistent, confused and contradictory patterns of largely arbitrary criteria. The diagnostic system wrongly assumes that all distress results from disorder, and relies heavily on subjective judgments about what is normal.”

Professor John Read, University of East London, said: “Perhaps it is time we stopped pretending that medical-sounding labels contribute anything to our understanding of the complex causes of human distress or of what kind of help we need when distressed.”


Source: University of Liverpool

08.07.2019

Read all latest stories

Related articles

Photo

News • Dementia destigmatisation

"This Is Us": Alzheimer's storyline in TV drama found to have positive impact

The inclusion of a narrative about Alzheimer’s disease in primetime TV drama “This Is Us” was found to help reduce stigma around dementia and motivate family discussions about plans for aging.

Photo

News • Restored brain waves

Brain stimulation improves depression symptoms

With a weak alternating electrical current sent through electrodes attached to the scalp, UNC School of Medicine researchers successfully targeted a naturally occurring electrical pattern in a…

Photo

News • Some problems remain

Some children can 'recover' from autism

Research in the past several years has shown that children can outgrow a diagnosis of autism spectrum disorder (ASD), once considered a lifelong condition. In a new study, researchers at Albert…

Related products

Arietta 650 DeepInsight

Ultrasound

Fujifilm · Arietta 650 DeepInsight

FUJIFILM Europe GmbH
iQ-VIEW

Reading

Image Information Systems · iQ-VIEW

IMAGE Information Systems Europe GmbH
Nova Biomedical – StatStrip Glucose/Ketone*

Blood Glucose

Nova Biomedical – StatStrip Glucose/Ketone*

Nova Biomedical Corporation
Sarstedt - COVID-19 virus diagnostics products

Saliva Collection

Sarstedt - COVID-19 virus diagnostics products

SARSTEDT AG & CO. KG
Sarstedt – CSF false-bottom tube

CSF and Alzheimer’s Disease Diagnostics

Sarstedt – CSF false-bottom tube

SARSTEDT AG & CO. KG
Sarstedt – Tempus600 Vita

Sample Logistics

Sarstedt – Tempus600 Vita

SARSTEDT AG & CO. KG
Subscribe to Newsletter