Disease analysis

No shortage of biobank donors

By definition, biobanks are collections of specimens of human bodily substances, such as tissue, cells, DNA, proteins, blood or other fluids, with data on the donor attached.

Report: Michael Krassnitzer

Pineal gland cyst from NAKO (in most cases this type of benign cyst is clinically irrelevant).
NAKO

They are well suited for large-scale population studies, for example to understand certain diseases better and to improve prevention, early detection and treatment. ‘Biobanks should also include radiology image data,’ says Professor Ritva Vanninen, at the Department of Clinic Radiology in Kuopio University Hospital, University of Eastern Finland.

After all, these images contain quantifiable parameters with prognostic or diagnostic value. ‘High quality image data and their reading by radiologists can be an important contribution to bio-medical research,’ Vanninen emphasises, adding: ‘vice versa, imaging biomarkers are validated by their use in research.’

Biobanks do not lack numbers

Portrait photo of Sabine Weckbach
Sabine Weckbach is Professor of Radiology and a consultant at the Clinic of Diagnostic and Interventional Radiology, in Heidelberg University Hospital.

As of 2014, the member states of the European Society of Radiology (ESR) have been operating 27 biobanks with imaging content. The British UK Biobank, with 500,000 donors, and the German NAKO Health Study collection, with 200,000 donors, are among the largest of these biobanks. Smaller ones were established inter alia in the context of the Dutch Rotterdam Study (approx. 15,000 donors) or the German SHIP study (approximately 8,700 donors). Upon request, both UK Biobank as well as NAKO make their data available for research purposes; these data are thus the foundation of many a research project. Modern digital methods to gain data, radiomics and machine learning, the buzzwords here, may at some point in the future contribute to the analysis of biobank content.

However, biobanks are not only a source of knowledge; they also raise a number of ethical issues: when collecting data that originally are meant to clarify the relationships between risk factors and diseases and the course of diseases, quite frequently incidental findings show up. How to deal with such data? Professor Sabine Weckbach, Consultant at the Clinic of Diagnostic and Interventional Radiology at University Hospital Heidelberg, offered the answer last March, during a session at the 29th European Congress of Radiology (ECR 2017), in Vienna, Austria. Weckbach is among the radiologists who analyse MR images acquired for NAKO. The so-called incidental findings, however, are neither incidental nor unexpected.


Invariably unplanned findings

Examinations with a 3-Tesla system, as prescribed for NAKO, will invariably yield unplanned findings. These may relate to acute diseases but also to diagnoses that are clinically irrelevant. ‘This raises a number of ethical issues,’ Weckbach points out. Which findings should be relayed to the donor and which of them should not be mentioned at all? How should these findings be conveyed, since physicians don’t want to scare donors with false positives? Each biobank and each large-scale population study approaches these issues differently. NAKO donors for example are informed in writing; if the incidental findings point at acute conditions they are contacted by telephone. NAKO clearly defined which kinds of diagnoses will be passed on to the donor and which will not.


Demanding more research

Unfortunately, there is not yet a gold standard

Sabine Weckbach

In view of the fact that there are so many different approaches to incidental findings, inevitably Weckbach demands more research: ‘Unfortunately, there is not yet a gold standard for handling incidental findings,’ the radiologist point out. We have to work on drafting harmonised guidance and recommendations for dealing with incidental findings in population-based studies.’

 

Profile:

Radiologist Sabine Weckbach studied medicine at Ludwig Maximilian University (LMU) in Munich, and today is Professor of Radiology and a consultant at the Clinic of Diagnostic and Interventional Radiology, in Heidelberg University Hospital. She specialises in musculoskeletal imaging, heads the Imaging Core Incidental Findings of Germany’s massive NAKO Health Study, and is a member of the European Society of Radiology (ESR) Leadership Institutes.

27.04.2017

Read all latest stories

Related articles

Photo

Block of erythrocytes formation

SARS-CoV-2 might attack red marrow

Specialists from the Department of Fundamental Medicine of Far Eastern Federal University (FEFU) with Russian and Japanese colleagues have probed into mechanisms of COVID-19 inside-the-body…

Photo

Mechanisms identified

Fanconi anaemia: Researchers find reason for bone marrow failure

Researchers at the University of Helsinki and the Dana-Farber Cancer Institute have identified the mechanism behind bone marrow failure developing in children that suffer from Fanconi anaemia. The…

Photo

From diagnostics to research

Clearing secondary use of clinical data

Re-using clinical data for research is an academic and organisational challenge, but there is much to gain from this to advance healthcare. During the January Triangle leadership meeting in Madrid,…

Related products

OR Technology ORCA - OR Cloud Archive

Portal Solutions

OR Technology ORCA - OR Cloud Archive

OR Technology (Oehm und Rehbein GmbH)
portal4med Referrer and Patient Portal

Portal Solutions

portal4med Referrer and Patient Portal

medavis GmbH
Sarstedt – Low DNA Binding Micro Tubes

Research Use Only (RUO)

Sarstedt – Low DNA Binding Micro Tubes

SARSTEDT AG & CO. KG
Agfa HealthCare – DR 100e

Mobile DR

Agfa HealthCare – DR 100e

Agfa HealthCare
Alsachim, a Shimadzu group company – Dosinaco

Clinical Chemistry

Alsachim, a Shimadzu group company – Dosinaco

Alsachim, a Shimadzu Group Company
Analyticon Biotechnologies AG - Urilyzer 100 Pro

Urinalysis

Analyticon Biotechnologies AG - Urilyzer 100 Pro

Analyticon Biotechnologies AG
Subscribe to Newsletter