Wearing personal protective equipment helps against an infection with Covid-19.
Wearing personal protective equipment helps against an infection with Covid-19.

Source: Shutterstock / theskaman306 

News • Personal protective equipment helps

Risk of Covid-19 infection among hospital staff lower than expected

Contrary to expectations, the risk of COVID-19 infection among hospital staff at the height of the coronavirus pandemic was lowest among intensive care clinicians, reveals a study of one major UK medical centre, published in the journal Thorax.
Infection risk was highest among cleaners, acute and general medicine clinicians, and those of Black, Asian and Minority Ethnic (BAME) backgrounds at University Hospitals Birmingham NHS Foundation Trust (UHBFT).

The findings prompt the researchers to suggest that the type of personal protective equipment (PPE) worn may be key to these differences, which are likely to be relevant for any second surge in COVID-19 and/or seasonal flu this winter.

UHBFT is one of the largest hospital trusts in the UK, with over 20,000 employees caring for 2.2 million people every year. As lead study author Professor Alex Richter explains in a linked podcast, at the height of the pandemic, 5 patients with serious COVID-19 infection were being admitted every hour. 

At the time, there was no national NHS staff testing capacity, so no way of knowing who was infected, and therefore at risk of passing it on to patients, or who had already had the infection. “You’ve got to remember that we are all key workers, so travelling on public transport, and out and about,” she says.

Recommended article

Photo

Sponsored • Fever Detection Camera

Improving Patients and Staff Safety with Non-Contact Fever Checks

In the course of the corona pandemic, hospitals and clinics are facing a serious challenge, as staff and patients are at increased risk of infection. Fever screenings are increasingly being carried out at entrances of healthcare facilities to identify persons with symptoms. Temperature checks are already part of daily operations at many airports.

To find out, she offered to test staff with no COVID-19 symptoms for both current (throat and nose swabs to detect antigen) and previous (blood test to detect antibodies) infection. “I’ve never recruited to a study so fast in my life. We recruited 545 staff in 20 hours,” she comments.

All the staff were at work over the course of 24 hours between 24 and 25 April 2020, around a month after the UK went into lock down. They were asked to report any illnesses consistent with COVID-19 that they had had in the previous 4 months. Information on ethnicity and department of work was also collected. 

Nearly 2.5% (13 out of 545) staff with no symptoms tested positive for SARS-CoV-2, the virus responsible for COVID-19 infection. Of these, 38% (5) subsequently developed COVID-19 symptoms. 

Around 1 in 4 (26%; 136) of the 516 for whom serum samples were available said they had previously had symptoms consistent with COVID-19 infection. 

Staff with previous symptoms were significantly more likely to have antibodies than those who hadn’t had symptoms: 37% (of 136 staff) vs 17% (of 281 staff). And they had higher levels of antibodies.

Workers in ITU are relatively well protected compared with other areas.

Alex Richter

The overall prevalence of antibody positivity (seroprevalence) was 24% (126/ 516): this compares with 6% generally in the Midlands at the time.

When the researchers looked at the figures by staff area, striking differences in antibody positivity emerged.

Cleaners had the highest seroprevalence (34.5%; 10/29), followed by clinicians working in acute medicine (33%; 10/30) or general internal medicine (30%; 30/99). The lowest seroprevalence was found among staff working in intensive care medicine (15%; 9/61), emergency medicine (13%; 2/15), and general surgery (13%; 3/23).

There was also an ethnic divide: workers of BAME backgrounds were nearly twice as likely to have already had the infection as their White colleagues.

“We presumed intensive care workers would be at highest risk. But workers in ITU are relatively well protected compared with other areas,” explains Professor Richter. 

“The reasons underlying this are likely to be multifactorial: in accordance with national guidelines, intensive care units were designated high-risk environments and the use of enhanced personal protective equipment (PPE) including filtered face piece (class 3) respirators mandated. In contrast, fluid-resistant surgical masks were recommended in other clinical areas,” note the researchers.

This is an observational study, and not all participants provided all the information requested. Nor is it known whether symptomless infection among staff puts hospital patients at risk.

“However, our data would support the assessment of widespread healthcare worker testing, including track and trace, on viral transmission during future waves of a pandemic,” conclude the researchers.

“All these factors are important for considering what’s going to happen this winter,”  suggests Professor Richter. “Cases [of coronavirus] are on the rise. Are we going to have another surge? If there is one, how do we protect healthcare workers this winter?” she asks.

“And let’s think not just about SARS-CoV-2 and the lessons we can learn for other pandemics, but seasonal infection. Influenza has a massive impact on the NHS every winter,” she adds.

Source: NIHR Birmingham Biomedical Research Centre

11.09.2020

Read all latest stories

Related articles

Photo

News • Reducing coronavirus test burden

AI speeds up COVID-19 screening in emergency rooms

Researchers from Eindhoven University of Technology (TU/e) and the Catharina Hospital in Eindhoven have developed a new algorithm for the rapid screening for COVID-19. The software is intended for…

Photo

Sponsored • Covid-19 management

Rapid and robust PCR testing for infectious diseases at Innklinikum Altötting and Mühldorf

The Covid-19 pandemic has highlighted the importance of the fast and accurate diagnosis of infectious diseases in clinical settings. Harald Maier discusses the implementation of rapid molecular…

Photo

Sponsored •  

Preanalytical challenges and their clinical impact in point-of-care testing

The European Society for Emergency Medicine (EUSEM) held their annual congress on October 27th to 31st, 2021 in the city of Lisbon, to promote education, training and research in European acute care.

Related products

Beckman Coulter – SARS-CoV-2 Assays

Immunoassays

Beckman Coulter – SARS-CoV-2 Assays

Beckman Coulter Diagnostics
Examion – X-DR Portable

Portable DR

Examion – X-DR Portable

EXAMION GmbH
Leonardo DR mini ll

Portable DR

Leonardo DR mini ll

OR Technology (Oehm und Rehbein GmbH)
Lifotronic  SARS-CoV-2 Antibody Detection Kit

Immunoassays

Lifotronic SARS-CoV-2 Antibody Detection Kit

Lifotronic Technology Co., Ltd
Lifotronic – SARS-CoV-2 Antigen

Immunoassays

Lifotronic – SARS-CoV-2 Antigen

Lifotronic Technology Co., Ltd
Lifotronic – SARS-CoV-2 Nucleic Acid Detection Kit

Detection

Lifotronic – SARS-CoV-2 Nucleic Acid Detection Kit

Lifotronic Technology Co., Ltd
Subscribe to Newsletter