MRIs may lead to unnecessary breast surgery

Women could be undergoing unnecessary breast surgery as a result of having magnetic resonance imaging, says an expert on bmj.com. In the last decade, says Malcolm Kell, Consultant Surgeon and Senior Lecturer at the Eccles Breast Screening Unit at University College Dublin, MRI or magnetic resonance mammography has become the most favoured type of investigation for high risk patients when combined with mammography and ultrasound.

Photo: MRIs may lead to unnecessary breast surgery

Kell says while magnetic resonance mammography (MRM) is extremely useful in monitoring advanced breast cancer and also to assess the response in the breast following chemotherapy, the use of this technology in early stage breast cancer may do more harm than good. He concludes that “there is no compelling evidence that this technique should be routinely used in newly diagnosed breast cancer.”

The author refers to one study in women with breast cancer who were being considered for treatment without surgery which shows a 6% increase for mastectomies in women who had an MRM compared to women who did not. He believes the higher rates of surgery could be because MRM is so sophisticated that it picks up harmless recurrence or extension of tumours whose removal will not alter the patient's prognosis.

While supporters of MRM say using it routinely is likely to pick up disease recurrence, the evidence does not back up their view, says Kell.

He argues that the best way to manage early stage breast cancer and reduce the need for unnecessary and invasive surgery is through yearly monitoring and drug treatment and radiotherapy where necessary.

 

Click here to read the full article

Picture Credit: Siemens Healthcare

22.10.2010

Read all latest stories

Related articles

Photo

GE invests in technology to tackle challenges in healthcare

Times may be tough, but GE Healthcare takes a longer term view, believing innovative technologies can transform healthcare delivery and help improve patient care.

Photo

31st German Senology Congress - More opportunities in breast diagnostics

Yes, it’s in beautiful Dresden again and -- as in 2006 when the city last hosted the Congress of the German Society for Senology -- this year’s Congress President is Professor Rüdiger…

Photo

Pre-operative breast MRI

Performing pre-operative breast MRI in all women with invasive lobular carcinoma (ILC) can reduce the need for re-excision, according to a study conducted through two major cancer centres - the…

Related products

Canon – Vantage Galan 3 T

3 Tesla

Canon – Vantage Galan 3 T

Canon Medical Systems Europe B.V.
Hitachi – Airis Vento Plus

Open

Hitachi – Airis Vento Plus

Hitachi Medical Systems Europe (Holding) AG
Hitachi – Aperto Lucent Plus

Open

Hitachi – Aperto Lucent Plus

Hitachi Medical Systems Europe (Holding) AG
Hitachi – Echelon Smart

1.5 Tesla

Hitachi – Echelon Smart

Hitachi Medical Systems Europe (Holding) AG
Hitachi – Oasis

Open

Hitachi – Oasis

Hitachi Medical Systems Europe (Holding) AG
Subscribe to Newsletter